Skip to content

田进勤 Tian Jinqin's Archive

This website presents a repository of documents and media developed following the first comprehensive study of the work of 田进勤 (Tian Jinqin), a pioneering figure in electronic music instrument design in China, conducted in collaboration with the author himself. In an upcoming publication, we introduce not only the biographical and contextual dimensions of Tian Jinqin’s contributions but focus particularly on his design principles, which anticipated many concepts later explored in Western academic discourse by several decades.

The materials on this website constitute the first digital archive dedicated to Mr. Tian Jinqin. They result from a visit and in-depth interviews conducted by Enrique Tomás and Martin Kaltenbrunner in February 2024, followed by ongoing conversations and weekly, if not daily, online exchanges between Enrique Tomás, Mr. Tian, and his son.

This study aims not only to highlight Tian’s importance within the history of Chinese music, as other authors have done, but also to understand deeply into his design decisions to inform the core aspects of his work. Our goal is to position his innovations as a bridge between traditional and contemporary China in terms of musical instrument development. Mr. Tian Jinqin was eager to share his experiences in designing electronic instruments and their interfaces; however, the relative obscurity of his work has left an extensive collection of academic, scientific, and artistic materials—including papers, schematics, sketches, and more—largely unrecognized. Organizing and translating these materials, as well as verifying them in consultation with Mr. Tian, has required over a year of dedicated effort.

As the first scholars likely to have engaged with Tian Jinqin’s complete body of published work since its inception, we recognize the critical importance of understanding the sociopolitical context in which he created his instruments and published his papers. For this reason, we are preparing both a book and a scholarly article on his work.

For more information please contact Enrique.Tomas@kunstuni-linz.at

Academic Publications

Tian Jinqin has written 12 academic publications. They are listed below.

Link to the digital repository (access only with permission – contact Enrique Tomás):

https://tamcloud.kunstuni-linz.at/s/DNikPYMY6DTzcBj

YearOriginal Title + EditorTranslated Title + EditorNotesAbstract
1974.3浅论电子乐器及其前景 (1974.3)

A Brief discussion on electronic musical instruments and their prospects (March 1974)

Unpublished. Made public by Fangmeng Jinqin on 28/12/2024 at his blog: https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/byyPg5ln2Vd_l8GgzK5lEA

Digital Version of the original document in Chinese available. English Translation available.
Signed with his name and position at the Radio Factory No.2 Taiyuan, it is still unpublished, This article describes the main differences between acoustic and electronic instruments, in the ways of generating sound and in the ways of performing with them, as well in their sonorities and the cultural values of each of the types. Before introducing electronic instruments, Tian Jinqin explains the existence of electrical (and amplified) instruments, their technologies, and how in fact the playing techniques do not differ too much from acoustic instruments. It is also presented the new possibilities that electronic music instruments propose
1982.3声音的调色盘-电子合成器(1982.3)


科学实验
Beijing : Ke xue chu ban she, 1970-1986
北京 : 科學出版社 1970-1986
v. : ill. ; 27 cm.
Sound Palette – Electronic Synthesizer (January 1981) pages 32-34

Scientific Experiments Journal

Beijing : Ke xue chu ban she, 1970-1986
北京 : 科學出版社 1970-1986
v. : ill. ; 27 cm.
Digital Version from the author available. English Translation available.Introduction of concept of sound effect synthesizer (oppposed to musical synthesizer) in the context of the public presentation of the DH-CC1 instrument created by Tian Jinqin. In this article the author explains the basic processes to create sound designs through synthesis, comparing it to the visual analogy of having a sound palette which have to be mixed to create new sound effects.
1984.1《电子乐器》专著,23万字(1984.1)

无线电爱好者丛书
电子乐器
田进勤编著
黄翔鹏审阅
责任编辑:沈成衡

人民邮电出版社出版 北京东长安街27号 河北省邮电印刷厂印刷 新华书店北京发行所发行
各地新华书店经售


开本:787×1092 1/32 1984年1月第一版
印张:10 页数:160 1986年6月河北第2次印刷
字数:228千字插页:3印数:20,001-31.000册
统一书号:15045·总2820-无6267
定价:1.65元
Monograph “Electronic Instruments,” (January 1984)

Radio Amateur Series
Electronic Musical Instruments

Compiled by Tian Jinqin
Reviewed by Huang Xiangpeng
Editor: Shen Chengheng
Published by People’s Posts and Telecommunications Press, No. 27 East Chang’an Street, Beijing, Printed by Hebei Post and Telecommunications Printing Factory, Distributed by Xinhua Bookstore Beijing Distribution Office
Sold by Xinhua Bookstores in various places

Format: 787×1092 1/32 First edition in January 1984
Printing sheets: 10 Number of pages: 160 Second printing in Hebei in June 1986
Number of words: 228,000 words Inserts: 3 Printing: 20,001-31.000 copies
Uniform book number: 15045·Total 2820-No 6267
Price: 1.65 yuan
Physical and Digital Version availableThis is a technical and theoretical book on the creation of synthesizers and electronic music instruments. From the oscillator circuits, filters, envelope controllers, to the techniques to play these instruments.
1986.3试论电子乐器的乐器化和民族化问题(1986.3)

田进勤 Tian Jinqin Archive X
发表于《音乐与午汤》
On the Issues of Instrumentation and Nationalization of Electronic  music Instruments (March 1986)

Tian Jinqin Archive
Published in the Journal 音乐与午汤
Digital Version from the author available. Document in two parts.Tian Jinqin says that most electronic music instruments in that moment are based on keyboards. This is an attempt to make electronic musical instruments “national”, understood as the interest to make musical instruments useful for Chinese music, or to better fit to the existing Chinese music.
1987.3译著《声音的电子合成原理及技术实践》(1987.3)Translation of “Principles and Technical Practice of Electronic Sound Synthesis” (March 1987)We only count with photos of cover, back cover page and the seven pages of the translator notes. The original articles can be found at https://www.worldradiohistory.com/Practical_Electronics.htm at 1982 (6,7,8) and 1983 (6,7). We downloaded a PDF version to the repository. English translation of translator comments available.Translation of five articles by A.R. Bradford published in the magazine Practical Electronics in 1982. Apart from the translation, Tian Jinqin writes a “translator comments” section where he contextualizes the original articles to the Chinese readers, and underlines the most important contributions of the original author, especially in regard to methods for controlling synthesizers, their sound quality, and a preliminar taxonomy of them.
1987.6唱奏式电子乐器【1987.6.3】Singing-Playing Electronic Instruments [June 3, 1987]Unpublished. Handwritten in Tian Jinqin’s notebook. Digital Version (photos) provided from the author availableIn this page of his notebook mr Tian describes a circuit that after capturing human voice through a microphone, creates synthetized sound following the envelope and frequency of the input.
1998.2“一人合唱团”试验电路(1998.2)

《安用电子立摘》•现代影音技术杂志•1998年第2期
https://www.cnki.net
“One-Person Choir” Experimental Circuit (July 1991)

Practical Electronic Digest, a magazine on modern audio-visual technology. Issue 2, 1998

Retrieved from China National Knowledge Infrastructure https://www.cnki.net
Digital Version from the author available. English translation available. Article explaining a preliminary circuit to create a one person choir. The author explains what particularly differences a choir from a single voice playing at unison at different pitches. Then he provides a circuit that takes audio from a microphone a shifts the pitch, having a second voice, but the resulting signal is fed back to the input so that groups of shifted voices are created in a type of chorus effect. Mr Tian presents it as a preliminary circuit to provoke others to continue the work.
1992影响主观音色感的非频谱因素探讨(1992年,第14届国际声学会论文)Exploration of Non-Spectral Factors Influencing Subjective Timbre Perception (1992, 14th International Acoustics Society Paper)Digital Version from the author availableIt is a paper on synthetizing timbre. Mr Tian departs from the observation that a sound can be described of coming from different instruments depending on the amplitude evelope and decorations used (portamento, glissando, etc) so that there is a mitmatch between objective timbre (what sounds) and what is perceived. Mr Tian point to inharmonic partials and transients as the source to perceived timbre.
1993电子乐器民族化问题再探(1993.12)Re-exploring the Issue of Nationalization of Electronic Instruments (December 1993)

93rd Annual Meeting of the Chinese Acoustical Society on Audio Engineering

Electroacoustic Technology 12/1993
Digital Version from the author available. English translation available.
This paper further explores the significance and content of the nationalization of electronic musical instruments, the electronic simulation of the timbre of national musical instruments, and the realization of the playing style of national musical instruments on electronic musical instruments. On this basis, a folk music electronic keyboard with the playing characteristics and timbre effects of national musical instruments has been developed.
The author emphasizes that the soul of “nationalization” is “instrumentalization”; successful timbre simulation is inseparable from the support of personalized performance techniques; and the expressiveness of instrumental performance cannot be separated from musical works with certain national artistic characteristics.
1994唱音美饰及音准矫正(1994)Singing Beautification and Pitch Correction (1994). Audio Engineering Society, 1994.

194 Audio Engineering Academic Exchange Conference and New Audio Products Exhibition Paper
Digital Version from the author available.
English translation available.

This is an academic paper published in the 1994 Academic Exchange Conference on Sound and Audio Engineering. In addition to discussing the object and content of various kinds of acoustic aesthetics, the paper specifically proposes the design of an electronic method for training singers to sing accurately.

With the rise of karaoke, the way of singing for self-entertainment using electronic devices has spread all over the streets and alleys. However, if these devices are not properly controlled or the singers have poor pitch, it will cause poor playback results and even become a kind of sound pollution. Therefore, the author proposes to develop two types of sound processing equipment: one is a singing voice beautifier, which is used to beautify the singer’s singing voice; the other is a pitch correction device, which is used to help singers practice singing with correct pitch.
This paper proposes and discusses the content and methods of vocal embellishment, as well as the design and practical significance of a pitch correction instrument.
1994.7米老鼠效应机理探析【1994年7月 电声技术】Analysis of the Mickey Mouse Effect Mechanism [July 1994,Electro-Acoustic  Technology]Digital Version from the author available.
English translation available.
The Mickey Mouse effect is the issue of using digital samples in pitch ranges very different from the original fundamental frequency of the original audio material. The author analyses different types of digital synthesis and how the inadequate use of samplers can result in synthesized audio with quite altered timbre. The author also analyses the cognitive and perceptual reason why we perceive it as unnatural or artificial, advocating for using other synthesis methods.
2004 (rev 2024)浅谈乐器中的“声”和“音”(2019年6月)


A Brief discussion on sound and tone (June 2019).

Article written in 2004, revised since then a few times. First time made public on 26.4.2024 at the website:
https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/QFWpQFl_lx2pPI0uG_fSrw

Original Digital Version from the author available. English translation available.

This article was first written in 2004 and has been revised many times by Tian Jinqin. In it, the author discussed the different notions of sound and tone when they are applied to audio synthesis. The author discusses how the articulation and timbre identification of the electronic music instrument depends mostly on the noisy part of the synthesis. Especially on the attack and transitioning part of enveloping audio. Tian Jinqin discusses the difference between synthetized sound and the phenomenological perception of sound by people, referring to two different things. For the author, the objective signal produced would still be called ”sound” while the perceived phenomenon could be called “Shen” 哂 (term coined by himself) to differenciate both.

Radio Magazine Publications

Tian Jinqin has contributed 57 times with articles in the Radio magazine. His articles are listed below.

Link to the digital repository (access only with permission – contact Enrique Tomás):

https://tamcloud.kunstuni-linz.at/s/DNikPYMY6DTzc


List of instruments

This list includes 21 instruments plus two add-ons to a keyboard. Certainly, Mr Tian Jinqin has created more instruments, prototypes, unfinished tests, etc. Here we are only listing the ones Tian Jinqin considered to be of considerable importance.

YEARNAMEDESCRIPTIONLINK TO PHOTONOTES
1958Electric Guzheng (modified DaZhengQin)“In 1958, I bought a second-hand DaZhengQin with the intention of modifying it into a small guzheng. To address the low volume, I used a homemade electronic tube amplifier to amplify the sound. However, after amplifying the sound, there were significant distortions in both sound quality and timbre. To correct this, I started using various filters. It was at this point that I discovered: using different forms of filters could greatly alter the sound and timbre of the guzheng, making it delicate like “spider silk” or deep and resonant like a grand bell!N/AIt has not been conserved
1958-1978Electronic Keyboard Instruments (self made)Self made electronic keyboards with tubes, metal keys, very primitive made of iron and springs. Because the sounds they produced could not imitate the traditional Chinese musical instruments, Tian Jinqin decided to create the string controlled instruments. In any case, he used these keyboards from 1960 to 1964  as accompaniment in several stage performances of traditional Chinese music.It has not been conserved. We only have photos.
1971Singing-Playing Electronic Instruments Tian Jinqin tried to develop an electronic musical instrument controlled by voice. Due to the difficulties. The process is explained in the publication “Singing-Playing Electronic Instruments” [June 3, 1987]Tian Jinqin first thought that he had developed this in the decade of the 80s, but after revising his records and notebooks after our inquiry he conformed that he worked between June and September 1971 on this project.
1978XK Ancestor (Prototype)Prototype of the XK instrument.The instrument was created for himself but it was the one he showed to the authorities in Beijing, allowing him to receive support to develop the XK instrument. After our visit in 2024 he decided to work again on the instrument and he remodelled various parts from the circuit and from the interface. We have photos from the original and from the new version.
1979XK-1 Four electronic ribbon strings with independent continuous control of pitch and volume.
The instrument was polyphonic, with one tone generator per string control.
The XK instruments did not incorporate any type of effects like reverb, delays, distorsion, etc. It was only the tone generators, filters, dividers, voltage controlled amplifiers, etc.
The performer could control a dynamic filter with the right knee.
At least 21 units were sold but none has been discovered.
1980电子音声合成器Electronic Sound SynthesizerModular and patchable synthetizer without keyboard. It could synthesize a variety of realistic scenes and natural sound effects, such as wind, rain, thunder, vehicles, honking, airplanes, guns, explosions, factory noise, crickets, birds, cows, horses and so on.
It can also synthesize a variety of unnatural sound effects, such as “through time and space”, “cosmic chorus”, “interstellar travel” and so on.
It was used as a workbench synthetizer to experiment and prototype sounds
1981DH-CC1电子音声合成器 DH-CC1 Electronic Sound Compress SynthesizerThis is the same electronic sound synthesizer as 电子音声合成器 (1980), and the reasons for the different times may be as follows: 1980 is the time when the synthesizer was developed. 1981 was his defining moment. The identification time is stated in the article “Sound Palette – Electronic Synthesizer” in the magazine “Scientific Experiments” in March 1982.13. It was used as a workbench synthetizer to experiment and prototype sounds
1982XK-2Extended and improved XK-1Never went into production
1982战地电子声模器 Electronic Battlefield Acoustic Simulators (1982.6)An instrument which can simulate the sound effects of a variety of battlefield equipment and guns. For military training.Because this is for the artillery unit, there are no public photos.It was produced and tested by the Chinese Army.
1984.9PD-1型普及多功能键盘电子琴  PD1 Universal Multifunctional Electronic InstrumentIt is a popular multi-functional keyboard electronic keyboard developed based on the M208 chip produced in Italy. It has a variety of musical instrument sound effects simulation and automatic rhythm accompaniment (percussion accompaniment and chord accompaniment) functions.It went into production
1984.12.3二音色电子胡琴 Two-tone Electronic HuqinThis electronic huqin has two sounds, one is the (ordinary) erhu and the other is the gaohu (treble erhu). There are two independent electric strings that can play two-note harmonies.Never went into production
1986.5.24)3D1多音色多功能电子琴 3D1 multi-timbre multi-function electronic instrument Children and amateur electronic keyboard. Use filter combinations to produce a variety of dynamic sounds. It is easy to arouse children’s interest in playing piano.It went into production and it was sold in different countries
1986.10.20. 3D-2型多种动态音色少儿琴 3D-2 Multiple Dynamic Tone Children’s PianoUsing the Chinese patented technology to produce a variety of dynamic tones of theprevious children’s electronic piano, so that the monophonic electronic piano can play magnificent musical effects. Adopts an integrated flat membrane keyboard to realize easy scratch playing.It went into production
1990.2.15DSP1型动态声效处理器 DSP1 Dynamic Sound Processing Unit (Electronic Music Processing Unit)An automated analog effects pedal that allows any music input (whether from tape, CDs, microphones, or electronic instruments) to automatically produce strange rhythmic timbral variations.
1990 – 力敏电子钢琴 Force-sensitive electronic pianoIt’s an 88-key electronic piano, featuring a key strength response that is continuously and infinitely layered (as opposed to the kind that usually only plays about 7-12 layers).It never went into production
199x自动报时钟音乐发生器 Automatic clock music generatorThis is a chime music generator add-on. It is designed to produce a preset musical chime when a chime pulse signal is received from the host computer.
There are no photos available as this is an add-on for the organ, not a whole unit.
199x自动打击乐节奏器 Automatic Percussion RhythmizerIt consists of a rhythmic beat point generator, a rhythmic content programming matrix, and various percussion unit circuits. More than ten typical rhythms such as tango, rumba, waltz, etc. can be generated. Again, since this is the unit mounted in the organ, there are no separate photos.
1986.6.16便携式弦控电子琴
 Portable string-controlled electronic instrument 
Portable string-controlled piano is one of my amateur design and production of electronic musical instruments. It is designed to be easy to carry around for performance or personal entertainment, so whether in terms of form factor or circuit conceptualization, it adopts the design principle of being light and small, beautiful and taking into account the performance of the instrument. The shape of the instrument is like a pentatonic note, and there is only one electric string for playing, but it can be used as four strings (GDAE), and it can also have the ability to harmonize in fifths. Therefore, it can be played like a violin instrument. This instrument has been continously updated and upgraded by Mr Tian, with new sensors and the fingerboard, a bow add-on, and a battery.
1987.5.4HT-22弦控琴 Chord Control InstrumentHT-22 was the name of a small chip that Tian Jinqin wanted to use for developing a miniature simple string-controlled instrument. But it was never finished. Never finished
1989.1.9电子吉他 Electronic guitar It is a kind of Hawaiian electronic guitar, later changed to force sensitive resistor diaphragm to replace the original electric string after the structure of practicality there are some problems to be overcome to improve.
1991电子扬琴
 Electronic dulcimer
Electronic dulcimer by circuit bending the interface of an existing Yamaha keyboard
1992.1波形存储式弦控琴
 Waveform Memory String Controlled Piano
This is a program that was started in 1994. The aim was to use the method of recording and storing the sound of an instrument as a sound source for performance in order to obtain a very realistic sound effect. Some results were achieved, but the research was discontinued because the “Mickey Mouse effect” (i.e., the resonance peak problem) could not be solved.
1996-2001电脑民乐琴(华琴)
(软件)

 Computer Chinese Musical Instrument (Hua Qin) (Software)
The Computer Folk Music Piano, also known as Huaqin, is a musical instrument software that can be played on Windows systems. It can colorfully play the musical effects of five traditional Chinese folk instruments: flute, erhu, pipa, guzheng and guqin using the computer keyboard. Simple ensemble effects can also be played with optional midi accompaniment.

Developed during Tian’s period in Shenzhen when he approached digital technologies.
2015 – 电子古筝
Electronic Guzheng
Sample-based instrument.1. Pentatonic scale rows (12356), with 4 or 7 obtainable with additional lifting keys.2. With a slice-playing keyboard.3. The main timbre is the guzheng (quadruple polyphony).4. There are eight non-guzheng timbres (e.g., guzheng shaking fingers, erhu, dongxiao, flute, violin, guqin, etc.) that can be used for soloing or ensemble work with the guzheng.5. The volume of the lead instrument guzheng and concertina instruments can be used for playing on any scale with a minor second, a major second, or a minor The volume of the lead instrument guzheng and the concertina can be controlled continuously with the left hand.7. It can be played by scraping the strings quickly in the pentatonic scale.8. When the guzheng is scraped, the slide is realized only in the last scale, so it will not produce the undesirable sound of the group slides.9. One of the particularly valuable ways of playing is that it can be realized by using the right wrist or the thumb to easily play slides or vibrato, the right wrist to play the upper slide, the right thumb to play the upper slide, the right thumb to play the lower slide, and the right wrist to play the upper slide, the right thumb to play the upper slide, and the right wrist to play the upper slide. The right wrist plays the upper slides and the right thumb plays the lower slides. This not only facilitates playing, but also frees up the left hand for more auxiliary operations, such as volume control, switching timbres, and so on.
2016Electronic UkeleleSample-based instrument in the form of a one-string ukelele. It has one metallic string connected to a physical mechanism controlling the envelope. Pitches are picked pressing the string between metallic self-made frets, which serve as a button array to decide the notes.

Other Inventions

YEARNAMEREFERENCE ARCHIVEPREVIEW NOTES
1991.6.29一人合唱团
 One Man Choir
This is a design intended to transform a person’s singing into a choir effect by means of electronic processing. An article entitled “A Choir Test Circuit” was published in the journal Practical Electronics Digest, but no prototype was made.
1992电子混响器
 Electronic reverb
This is an electronic reverb realized with an electronic bucket chain BBD integrated circuit, successfully used in a portable string-controlled piano.
1993无线话筒混响器
Wireless Microphone Reverberator
It is the addition of a wireless transmitter circuit to the Bucket Chain Reverberator, which transmits a frequency that can be picked up by a receiver next to the mixing console.
1994手绘波形产生器
 Hand-drawn waveform generator
This is an experimental device developed to quickly study the dependence of timbre on waveform. Any waveform can be drawn manually and then immediately pronounced while listening to its timbre effect. The waveform is stored in an EEPROM, which can be written and erased many times
1995.7.10电子节拍器
 Electronic metronome
This is an electronic metronome with sound and light indicators to train players or singers to recognize the isochronous nature of the beat. The metronome offers the most commonly used types of beats: 2/4, 3/4, 4/4, and can be used for training with the sound indicator on, and for recording with the light indicator to ensure that the metronome sound is not recorded.
2009.3二胡扩律器Mechanical Tranformation of ErhuThe erhu expander is a method of expanding the erhu without changing its original structure and form by attaching external parts, so as to increase the interval of a pure fourth in the direction of the lowest note on the original basis. The result is equivalent to adding a bass string. The erhu expander is this attachment. It is purely a mechanical design.

External Referecences used by Tian Jinqin

Due to limitations in resources, obtaining reference materials was quite challenging. In the 1950s, 1960s, and 1970s, I relied on self-funded subscriptions to domestic and international magazines, as well as the purchase of relevant Chinese and foreign books for reference. Due to my limited financial budget, the pool of available scientific and technological literature for reference was quite meager. Consequently, I had to tread a solitary path, exploring and experimenting on my own.

YEARNAMEARCHIVE LINKCONTENTS NOTES
1962-2019Publications https://tamcloud.kunstuni-linz.at/s/DNikPYMY6DTzcAcademic, Radio Amateur, Scientific Experiments and notebook publicationsThis archive of publications is complete. Some files are PDF, many are photos from the publications, some are scans from the original. Still this has to be compiled and OCR.

Other websites, media, Youtube, Bibilibi, etc:

First video of the Dian Zi Qin documentary uploaded (31-7-2017): https://web.archive.org/web/20191003230606/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t31IoRkIn7Y&gl=US&hl=en

First Interviews:

https://zhuanlan.zhihu.com/p/40765177

https://zhuanlan.zhihu.com/p/39702179

RADII: https://radii.co/article/video-inside-the-studio-and-instruments-of-chinas-first-electronic-music-pioneer

Meng Qi Interview’s: part1 (https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1Mg411D7gX/?spm_id_from=333.337.search-card.all.click) and part 2 (https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1FY4y1M7y3/?spm_id_from=333.337.search-card.all.click)

Interview by Sandy: https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV18t411D77b/?spm_id_from=333.337.search-card.all.click

The lost keys of China:

https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV18t411D77b/?spm_id_from=333.337.search-card.all.click

https://www.midifan.com/m/news_body.php?id=41336

https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/KRNVnx115urK2zXR2JK_QQ

https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/KRNVnx115urK2zXR2JK_QQ

http://midiplus.com/author_html_20220108/Tianen.html

https://m.midifan.com/news_body.php?id=41336

https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1FY4y1M7y3/

https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1Mg411D7gX/

https://radiichina.com/video-inside-the-studio-and-instruments-of-chinas-first-electronic-music-pioneer

https://radiichina.com/watch-1980-video-of-tian-jinqin-originator-of-chinese-electronic-music

https://cdm.link/2018/04/amazing-touch-controlled-synth-made-secret-1978-china

https://zhuanlan.zhihu.com/p/40765177

https://www.cndzq.com/bbs/thread-5106-1-1.html

https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/RLDul8I0e16zgXxJ86Bnew

https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/QFWpQFl_lx2pPI0uG_fSrw

https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/AMIvBv1K9fDT3kX9qW5W-A

Related Publications